Stupid Patent Case of the Week

I’m sick of the current state of affairs of the U.S. patent ecosystem.  Among my many frustrations, this is certainly high on the list.  My partner Brad also feels the same way.  While Brad has blogged extensively, with some help from me before I wrote my own blog, I’ve been silent lately. 

But I recently heard about a case that made me want to vent.  Get this…

The patent at question is a business method patent concerning sharing confidential information over the Internet.  Yes, someone has a patent on sending confidential information over the Internet.  This is novel?  Like, "duh."  Shame on the patent office for granting this patent.

If that wasn’t bad enough, he is suing a whole bunch of companies (including Microsoft and Monster.com) trying to hold them up for money.  See the filing here.  It is 4 pages long and what probably took this guy’s lawyer 15 minutes to compose will destroy millions of dollars in aggregate shareholder value simply defending this suit. 

But it gets better!  The plaintiff, Michael Powell is a lawyer at Quinn Emanuel, whose wife is his attorney.   According to my sources, he was unsuccessful as an entrepreneur and now with his solely owned LLC that has this one and only patent and no apparent business operations, he’s decided to take his legal education and do something good for our society: becoming a patent troll.

It’s really a travesty that a guy whose couldn’t raise the money to continue to run the business and shut his company down in 2001 waits around 7 years and then files this case claiming that he has a right to money based on an obvious “invention” and furthermore deserves money as a non-practicing entity against companies out there trying hard to run their businesses. 

Mike, you not making enough money as a lawyer?  You really feel like you added value to our society creating this patent?  You really feel this is what the patent system was designed for?  You should be absolutely ashamed.  Congrats on being yet another example of a lawyer giving all the good ones a bad name.  I wish all the best to the lawyers representing the defendants. 

  • Hahaha, that's pretty stupid! People need to get educated!

  • Anonymous

    In chanel bags line, various excellent and popular series which also sold well in the market that are always out of supply quickly when the bags that released in the market. For thesechanel outletwhich also sold well, especially for the chanel 2.55 series which sold extreme well. Chanel Handbagsare well known for their clean lines and top quality materials. The polished chain and bold brand symbol on every bag sets them apart from their peers.   http://www.chanelhandbagsshop.net/ 

    Gucci Handbagswhich are mainly known for its striped webbing pattern design, which come along with a style staple to say the least. Fashion ladies bags lovers all like to own thegucci bagsin hand to show her status. Luxury styles consists of nuances which tends to make the handbags even fancier, which consists of multi-colored patent leathers, horse shoe harware, chains, python, tassels jointly with other touches byGucci outlet’s talented designers. http://www.guccisales.net/

    Based on the marketing research, herve leger dress clothes that seems to be a fashion brand that lead the fashion trend and most worn by the rich women and famous stars. Our herve leger outletthat supply you sexy design and signature bandage dress, all come in fashion design and unique styles. So would you also like to get the herve leger bandage?  http://www.hervelegerdresssales.net/

    Though there are various designer handbags brands among the worldwide, people all like the Gucci Bags especially for the businessmen. It is the excellent design in styles that appear to be in which favored so many consumers. Lots of people purchase theGucci Handbags for the elegant style such definitely can make you a higher status. And we are a gucci outlet online for you to choose from.  http://www.guccistoresonline.com/

    Both the external and inside oflouis vuitton handbagsauctions these signature bags are visually delightful. What’ more, the price that seems fairable. Due to the fact that online shopping is becoming more and more popular, so people would like o get the louis vuitton bags online. And we are a great lv bags outletonline which earns high reputation. Just purchase here. You would definitely like the louis vuitton outletwith excellent quality. http://www.louisvuittonhandbags-mall.com/

    Always you will find the famous stars carry the louis vuitton bags in hand when attending some parties or other celebrities. Definitely due to the top quality that applied in as well as the unique styles that designed in, so all the louis vuitton handbagsthat do not come cheap price. However in ourlouis vuitton outletonline, we on sale all kinds of excellent discount lv bags. http://www.louisvuittonbags-malls.com/ 

    One way for some people to get duped into buying Gucci handbags is when they hear about and come to bargained items sales, midnight markets, and the like. You’ll find there, amasingly low priced, products of all kinds, but rarely will the actual items there be the real thing. Bargains aren’t bad on their own, but if you’re looking for the real Gucci bags, it’s best to find trusted stores. The Gucci outlet store can point you to stores in your vicinity. http://www.guccibagshot.com 

    Louis Vuitton outlet store as one of the most luxurious brand in the world, is famous for leather goods loved by so many enthusiasts, which brings a huge business opportunity for market. We are professional trader for wholesale Louis Vuitton handbags, aiming at filling large demands as well as leading fashion trends. http://www.louisvuittonbagshot.com